Dissertation Literature review notes

Assignment 2: Dissertation, Dissertation

Key points to discuss in the literature review

  1. The lack of knowledge about 2D animation
  2. Market demands for 2D animation
  3. Pulling Factors- advantages, disadvantages, cost, production time
  4. Popularity of 2D animation

These 4 topic subheadings will be used to help me to come up with some evidence that supports my chosen topic and these subheadings. Furthermore these subheadings will help me to focus my research studies/ references on these key points. These subheadings also help me to stick to the main focus point of 2D and my chosen topic title “The lack of knowledge in the market and pulling factors for 2D animation.” Therefore I need to work on finding some sources and evidence that helps proof this problem.

Dissertation: Lecture Notes & Draft notes

Assignment 2: Dissertation, Dissertation

At Least a final draft for Dissertation by the end of January 2019

Structure and collecting data analysis

  • Literature review- what is already out there about your topic
  • Books, Journals, Websites- Analysing them
  • Primary research- in gathering data for discussion and analysis
  • Need to do questionnaire for public and professional opinions
  • Questions only relating to “The lack of knowledge in the market and pulling factors for 2D animation.”
  • In Dissertation guide- results
  • What you have found from primary and secondary data.
  • Analysing data you have found out.
  • Have at least 3 supervision meetings

Dissertation draft notes

Methods/ Methodology

  • Secondary research: Journals, Books, websites
  • Primary research: Questionnaire & results from animation students and industry professionals

Things to discuss in the literature review/ dissertation

  • 2D animation
  • Lack of Knowledge about 2D animation
  • 2D animation market
  • Advantages and Disadvantages of 2D animation
  • Pulling factors: Cost, Quality, Style, Production time, Budget

2D animation market- is there still a market?

15/20 questions in Questionnaire

  • Is 2D animation dead?
  • Is 2D still being used?
  • Why is 2D animation in short demand?
  • When was 2D animation popular?
  • Why was 2D animation popular?

Dissertation draft notes

  • Different sources to support argument
  • Clarity of argument- points across make more clear
  • Analysis- Lack of 2D animation produced, why is this?
  • What are the advantages and disadvantages of 2D animation
  • Pulling factors of 2D animation:
  • Cost
  • Budget
  • Quality
  • Production time
  • Style

Popularity of 2D animation in Europe, USA

Why is it popular in these areas?

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dissertation Proposal Feedback & Topic changes

Assignment 2: Dissertation, Dissertation

Proposal Feedback

  • 2:2
  • Structure paragraphs
  • Literature review- supports key points- not key terms or keywords
  • Don’t know if 2D is still a viable medium- is this a problem?

Dissertation Topic changes

Problem

  • There is a lack of knowledge about the market and pulling factors for 2D animation
  • Market
  • Pulling factors

Knowledge gap

  • This is what people will learn from your dissertation
  • Make clear if 2D animation is still a suitable market for animators to work in.
  • As might come out of university and not know if there is a market for 2D animation

Problem Purpose statement notes

Evidence

  • Sources on the lack of knowledge into the market and pulling factors for 2D animation

Context

  • Time- 5- 10 years
  • Place- Europe and America
  • People- Animation students, emerging animators, new students, young people involved/ studying animation and potential investors into animation
  • Produce- Literature review and methodology

Analysis of findings

  • Literature review- Knowledge gap
  • Avoid 3D and other mediums
  • Competition- 3D films/ Animation
  • Only for aspect of competition
  • Groups of people prefer 2D animation
  • Which groups of people prefer 2D animation

Methodology

  • Statistical data in 2D
  • Case studies into 2D
  • Secondary quantitative data
  • Studios- Animation produced, why?

Literature review

  • What is good about 2D?
  • 2D production?
  • Why is it produced?
  • Rephrase questions in proposal so they are only for 2D
  • Want to give animators a justification for is 2D animation still in the market
  • e.g What are the unique attractions to 2D animation
  • This dissertation is only about 2D animation

 

 

 

Dissertation Writing: Lecture Notes #2

Assignment 2: Dissertation, Dissertation

Abstract

  • Topic- 2 Sentences explaining the basics of your topic

Acknowledgements

  • People that have taken part in your research

Technical Document (Primary research)

  • Introduction- topic
  • Literature review
  • Action research- Primary and Secondary
  • Analysis

Either produce different videos discussed

Primary Research

  • Chosen Topic
  • Comparing your own work to industry work
  • Literature review proves/ backs up your topic (Evidence)
  • Do not have to produce a animation- your own analysis on other animations and write about them
  • 70% Action research
  • 30%- What is already out there

Generic Dissertation Proposal Feedback

Paragraph construction and Sentence construction

  • Paragraph- write with multiple sources rather than based on one source
  • No source at the top of the paragraph
  • No First person
  • ONLY THIRD PERSON!
  • Literature review- only literature not videos
  • Films/ videos- not academic literature- unless it is  analysing documentary
  • Cannot have majority of literature review being videos

Videos/ DVD in research

  • Literature review- how has the issue been discussed/ mentioned before
  • Not about findings, what is out there at the moment
  • What is already out there about your topic

Methodology

  • Not just what research you are using, but why?
  • Justification!
  • Why/ where did you see it
  • Planning- Indicate what activities will you be doing
  • Structure- the structure on handbook

Paragraph writing framework

  • Introducing- introduction to paragraph
  • Give an example- study of
  • Reinforce- Source (more than 1)
  • Critique- Analyse
  • Conclude- What is your point
  • Transition- Link back to main topic
  • Synthesis- different sources/ bring different perspectives

Example

  • Stop motion choice or preference?
  • Give an example- can be argued that Stop motion is a choice based on quality and preference
  • Bring in sources- where is the proof? Evidence (Quotes), Research
  • Example and reinforced
  • Critique- Bring in arguments against and for, this example- bring in another source
  • Need arguments/ discussions in your critique section
  • Conclude- Brought in another source as to why you are critiquing it
  • Conclusion- In your resources you found it was based on quality
  • Transition- Transferring from one point to another
  • What other arguments/ discussions do you need to talk about
  • Transition example- the quality of Stop motion hasn’t always been appreciated as a preference in terms of taste/ theme.
  • Thinking about the next key point/ paragraph

Critique writing and thinking

  • Bringing in different sources to provide evidence for your point

Dissertation: Problem Purpose Statement Lecture notes

Assignment 2: Dissertation, Dissertation

Problem Purpose Statement

  • A4 document

Research documents are essentially…

Step 1: “What is the problem?”

  • Mind Map (1-2 sentences)

Step 2: Knowledge gap

  • all information that is available (Literature review) something your topic will address that is not in any literature!
  • “What are we going to learn that is new?”

Step 3: Context

  • Time
  • Place
  • People
  • Involved in dissertation
  • Time period- e.g Modern day
  • Place- UK/ America/ etc
  • People- Men/ Women/ Animators/ etc

Step 4: Conceptual Framework

  • Leave this out (N/A)

Step 5: Evidence/ Logic

  • Important enough to do research
  • Provide evidence to support why this problem needs to be researched

Data used: Primary or Secondary

Dissertation Writing: Lecture notes

Assignment 2: Dissertation, Dissertation

After Proposal- Making Dissertation

  • Not about contents but about Methodology
  • Understanding the social world
  • Interacting/ interaction in different levels (Social)
  • What methods are you going to use?
  • Social science- coherent body of thought about a topic
  • Personal opinions, preferences and Speculative- NO PLACE!

Methods of gathering data

  • Different perspectives on a given phenomenon
  • Informs alternative methods of gathering information
  • Role of a researcher- understand and explain phenomenon
  • Depends on a mixture of boldly innovative thought
  • Evidence to support or discomfort a hypothesis and theories
  • All theories can be tested and philosophised

Social Sciences

  • Systematic gathering of data
  • Objectivity, Positivism, Realism, Subjectivity, Idealism
  • Postmodernism
  • No one is “Positivism” all collecting numbers (Quantitative)
  • Methods and types of data should collect is open to dispute

Objectivity

  • Determining the nature of rationality, knowledge, truth, reality, goodness or rightness
  • Assumes own values do not enter into our research
  • Impossible for unrated dissertation
  • You choose your topic

Positivism

  • Philosophical system recognising only that which can scientifically verified or which is capable of logical or mathematical proof.
  • Beliefs in adding figures to conclude
  • Collect data and assemble social world.

Secondary research

  • Involves using information that others gathered through primary research
  • This is a secondary research study, gathered 5 different studies like:
  • Accessible via databases
  • Reanalysing, interpreting or reviewing past data

Secondary research 4 steps:

  1. Develop research questions
  2. Identify secondary data set
  3. Evaluate a secondary data set
  4. Prepare and analyse secondary data

Step 1- “Relevant” for this research 

  • Provide rational information
  • Why did you do it?
  • Why did you choose data?
  • Relevant to my study?

Step 2- List of Databases for research

  • Sherlock
  • List of websites
  • Design a 2 column table
  • Included studies
  • Excluded studies
  • Under table- write paragraphs
  • Why did you include these studies?
  • Why did you exclude these studies?

Step 3- Explain the “Method” of analysing data

  • This chapter explores/ explains the methodology used in the study
  • Article eccentric matrix
  • Table including: Methodology
  • Focus groups
  • Include findings of methodology
  • Critical Evaluate (Optional)
  • Most Important! Methodology
  • What is the study?
  • What is the methodology?
  • What is the findings?
  • After talk about similarities and differences

Matrix of study

  • Only use one table
  • Step 1- Introduction
  • Step 2- Research design (table)
  • Step 3- Similarities and differences
  • Step 4- Analysis- Explain what you did

Chose this study because of the objectivity

Methodology Structure

  • Introduction
  • Qualitative research design
  • Primary data
  • Secondary data
  • Literature search
  • Method of sampling and recruitment
  • Data collection methods
  • Documentary analysis
  • Data Analysis

Qualitative Methodology

  • How did you go about your research?
  • What overall strategy did you adopt and why?
  • What design and techniques?

Methodologies

  • Case studies
  • Evidence based design research
  • Analysis research
  • Development research
  • Parametric research
  • Operation research

Methods

  • Observational studies
  • State of Art review
  • Content analysis
  • Data analysis
  • Experimental design
  • Data Qualification
  • Literature review
  • Photography

Justification for different methods used

Types of Research

  • Exploration research
  • Conclusive research

 

 

 

 

Dissertation Research Proposal (Final Document)

Assignment 1: Dissertation Research Proposal, Dissertation

50194030_Dissertation_Research_Proposal_V11

Above is my final research proposal document containing;

  • Research Topic
  • Research Questions
  • Abstract
  • Literature review
  • Methodology
  • Structure
  • Timetable of completion
  • Bibliography

Using the previous feedback comments I have read through my document and made the necessary changes to each section in the proposal. Therefore I have creating this final proposal to propose my research topic to the ethical committee, providing evidence of Quantitative and Qualitative data that I will be using in this essay to support the discussions, arguments and justifications for “If 2D animation is still viable in the growing film industry?”.

Ethical Review form & Participant and Consent Form

Assignment 1: Dissertation Research Proposal, Dissertation

50194030_Ethical_Review_Form_UAL_V5

Above is the Ethical review form and the Participant & Consent form, required to carry out my primary research in the investigation I am conducting in my dissertation project. These forms are important for indicating the ways I will be conducting the primary research with participants in the public and professional industry. Therefore I had to produce these documents in order to provide written consent and awareness of the studies participants will be involved with in this investigation. Furthermore the Ethical review form allows the Ethical committee to approve my research topic allowing me to produce my dissertation project on that specific research topic.

Dissertation Research Proposal- Feedback

Assignment 1: Dissertation Research Proposal, Dissertation

50194030_Dissertation_Research_Proposal_feedback_V1

Above is a document that contains some feedback into improving my research proposal. My tutor read through my proposal and gave my some comments on how to fix the spelling and grammar, as well as improving the overall proposal I have written previously. Therefore this document will be used as a reference to develop my previous version of my research proposal so that I have a clear proposal, that provides a clear understanding on my research topic, with evidence to support my discussions, arguments and justifications.